Avid's ACE survey finds editors give AI the chores and temp shots, never the cut
Avid asked 120 members of American Cinema Editors how they use AI. Most of the 77.5% who do lean on tools already inside their editing software, only 42 use it weekly, and the 27.5% who generate images or video keep it to temp material. Avid wrote the questions, sells the tools and has not said how respondents were found.

Avid's survey of 120 members of American Cinema Editors (ACE), run with the society in the second quarter of 2026, found 77.5% already use AI in their work, regularly, occasionally or experimentally. Avid published the results on Friday 16 October. Variety reported them on Friday 13 November as new data.
The headline number hides where the line sits. Most of that use is machine help already built into editing software, transcription, audio cleanup and search, and only 42 of the 120 use AI daily or weekly. Generation is not fringe either: 27.5% already make images or video, under a rule Avid's own write-up spells out, temp material in, the final cut out. Variety mentioned generation without a figure, and neither it nor the ShowBiz rewrite we read noted that Avid sells the tools, wrote the questions and came top of its own trust ranking.
What the editors told Avid
Asked which areas they use AI for, 60% picked transcription, 55% audio cleanup and 39.2% search and discovery. Image or video generation was fourth, with 27.5% of editors using it. When each editor named the one capability that would help most, 81.7% chose work around the edit, while rough cut or assembly help drew 7.5%. That question offered no generation option at all.
Use is also thinner than the 77.5% suggests. By the group sizes in Avid's charts, 42 editors (35%) use AI daily or weekly, 23 monthly and 55 rarely or never. Among the heavy users, 76.2% said AI had made them faster, against 18.2% of the rare users. Those are self-reports, not measured time savings. The biggest barrier was ethics, copyright and security at 49.2%, far ahead of creative quality at 13.3%. And 86.7% agreed AI is most valuable when it enhances creative intent rather than replacing it, rising to 97.6% of the heavy users.
The temp rule, in their words
Avid's blog post on the results, titled Everything But the Cut, quotes open answers from anonymous respondents. One editor described using ElevenLabs for temp ADR and Midjourney to illustrate potential pickup shots, then wrote that they could not see a way it would be useful for final outputs. Another has set a personal rule that AI material "will only be used for temp purposes, never in a final." A third put the whole survey in two sentences: "I don't want to generate an image. I want the AI to transcribe footage or find lines I'm looking for."
Avid draws the contrast itself. Its post notes generation trails transcription, cleanup and search, "Yet generation is precisely what most of this technology is marketed on." Twenty-five days later, on Tuesday 10 November, Avid launched Ready to Play, Google's Gemini and Veo inside Media Composer, pitched as temp footage, and cited the survey's heavy-user figures as an endorsement.
Molly Shock, an Emmy-nominated reality editor, gave Variety the clearest case. On a recent season of MasterChef, the first with AI tools, producers needed a contestant checking the clock. A search that once took hours took seconds, she said, because the system recognizes contestants and answers a request like "John does time check." Her verdict was about time rather than speed: "I wouldn't say I'm more efficient. It just gives me more time to do the really fun part of editing, the real creative stuff."
How much weight the 77.5% can carry
It can carry less than the headline asks. Avid has not published how respondents were recruited, the response rate or any weighting, and its definition of use includes experimenting. The sample is about 8% of ACE, which describes itself as having over 1,500 members, not the 1,200 Variety printed, and ACE is an honorary society of senior editors, not the profession at large. The report says it "shares every result", but we could find about 13 of its 17 questions across the PDF and the blog. Avid led its own trust question at 39.2%, ahead of Adobe at 15%, with no model company offered as an option.
The coverage also left out two context points, and neither suggests the quotes are unfair. Shock sits on the board of the Motion Picture Editors Guild, and in 2022 she appeared on The Rough Cut, a podcast Avid's Matt Feury hosted, the same Feury who spoke for Avid in Variety's story. Reaction on X was small and pointed in the same direction as the data: replies to Variety's post said much of this is search and cleanup rebranded as AI.
What it means for AI creators
- The open door in a pro edit bay is temp material: previs, pickup illustrations, placeholder shots and temp voice that help a cut get approved.
- The work editors want help with is the grind around the cut, so tools that log, sync, search and clean footage have the warmest buyers.
- Rights come first in that room. Ethics, copyright and security worry editors almost four times as much as image quality, so clear licensing is a stronger pitch than prettier output.
- Anything sold as making the cut itself is pushing against 86.7% of the people who would have to use it.
Our take
It is a vendor's survey, but the useful finding survives the caveats. Professional editors have already decided where generative AI goes, and it is the rehearsal, not the show. For anyone making AI footage, that is a real market with a clear brief: be the best temp in the room, and leave the cut to the editor.
Timeline
- Date: Mon 7 Feb 2022. Event: Molly Shock and the MasterChef: Legends editors appear on The Rough Cut, hosted by Matt Feury; Source: theroughcutpod.com
- Date: Apr to Jun 2026. Event: Survey fielded: 120 ACE members, 17 questions; Source: Avid report
- Date: Mon 31 Aug 2026. Event: Media Composer 2026.8 ships PhraseFind AI Multicam Auto Cut; Source: Avid
- Date: Fri 16 Oct 2026. Event: Avid publishes the results in its blog post Everything But the Cut; Source: Avid resource center
- Date: Tue 10 Nov 2026. Event: Avid launches Ready to Play with Gemini and Veo and cites the survey; Source: Avid press room
- Date: Fri 13 Nov 2026. Event: Variety reports the survey; ShowBiz rewrites it the same day; Source: Variety, ShowBiz
Sources and what is unconfirmed: Avid, AI in Post: By the Numbers (PDF, charts read figure by figure) and blog post Everything But the Cut, 16 Oct 2026; Avid Ready to Play release, 10 Nov 2026; Variety, 13 Nov 2026; ShowBiz, 13 Nov 2026; ACE event programs (membership); Television Academy and Motion Picture Editors Guild records (Shock); X replies to Variety's post, 7 days to 16 Nov. Unconfirmed: how respondents were recruited, ACE's role beyond partnership, which tool ran the MasterChef search, and how Variety reached Shock. We did not contact Avid, ACE or Shock.
Your Voice
80% of editors use AI because their search bar has become an AI-powered search bar and their one click audio cleanup has become an AI powered one click audio cleanup.
The ONLY AI I use, in Avid, is for Transcripts of scenes. Just to find words and phrases. And that replaced PHRASEFIND, which was not AI.
Leaving out a lot of details and nuance on your polled data in this article. Most of the tools in Media Composer are not GENAI they are more ML.
Quoted from public posts on X and credited by handle. If one of these is yours and you want it removed, message @the__generated on X and it comes down.
Got something to say? Tag @the__generated on X