Judge says Runway must face YouTube creators' lawsuit over scraped training videos
A New York judge refused to dismiss a class action alleging Runway got around YouTube's download protections to train its video models. It is a pleading-stage ruling: nothing is proved, and Snap and ByteDance lost the same motion earlier.
Businessing LLC, the company behind Ali Spagnola's YouTube channel, says at least 1,200 of its videos were scraped to train Runway's video models. Ace Cam, which runs the Random Golf Club channel, says 390 of its own were. On Oct 30, Judge Lewis Kaplan in New York refused to throw out their class action.
The claim is not copyright. It says Runway got around YouTube's download protections, such as IP blocking, expiring links and CAPTCHAs, which a US law bars. Runway argued anyone can watch these videos free, so nothing was locked. Kaplan wrote that public viewing still runs through YouTube's protections.
Everything here is allegation. The judge assumed the complaint's facts were true and found nothing proved. Snap and ByteDance lost the same motion earlier, and an appeal in a separate case could still undo the reasoning. Runway has made no public statement that we could find. Nothing changes for people using its tools today.
Our take: whether video model makers say where their footage came from, and ask or pay first, is now a question three judges have let proceed.
Source: U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y. opinion of Oct 30, 2026, and case dockets.
Read the full article: thegenerated.com/stories/runway-youtube-dmca-lawsuit-ruling-20261030







